Fill out form 1 and form 2
Included the previous form because this is the continue work. Keep in mind that for this phase of the process all of the articles should be related to establishing why the problem exists and then in the next phase the articles all pertain to finding possible solutions to the problem
| DDHA 8113 Article Analysis Worksheet | |
Instructions: For each of the articles that you select, complete this chart in its entirety. You may copy the chart as many times as needed to fulfill the Assignment requirements.
|
Article APA Reference |
|
Justification/Rationale for Study |
|
Gap in Practice |
|
Purpose of the Study (Include list of independent variables [IVs] and dependent variables [DVs]) |
|
Theoretical or Conceptual Framework |
|
Study Design and Sampling Procedures |
|
Data Collection Procedures |
|
Data Analyses Used |
|
Description of Significant Results |
|
Discussion of Findings, including Limitations of the Study |
© 2022 Walden University, LLC Page 1 of 3
,
Integrative Review Literature Search Planning Form
This form is a starting point to help you brainstorm your search strategy while refining your research question. We strongly recommend consulting with a librarian when developing your search strategy. Go to Ask a Librarian in the Walden Library to email the Library team or to schedule an appointment.
Purpose:
Aim:
|
Key Concepts, Synonyms, Search Terms |
Inclusion criteria |
Exclusion criteria |
|
|
Population |
|||
|
Problem of interest |
|||
|
Context or Outcomes |
|||
|
Literature/Study Types (be inclusive) · Qualitative · Quantitative · Observational · Theoretical · Experimental · Case reports · Meta-analysis · Mixed methods · Other Data Collection Methodology Browser |
Literature Types Include: What literature did you expect to find and what didn’t you find? |
Library Guide to the Literature Review and the Checklist for Exhausting the Literature. |
|
|
Publication limits for Inclusion/Exclusion Any reason the search should be limited by date and/or language? Years of publications Languages – English (unless there is a reason to include other languages) |
|
Please list 5-10 relevant references to represent the articles expected in the results (include PMID or DOI, if possible): |
|
1. 2. 3. |
|
Potential Databases/Search Strategies These databases are provided as examples. Talk to a librarian to explore other possible databases and see the Walden Library for other subject areas and combined-database search options. Linked to Walden Library subscriptions. |
||
|
Databases: Medicine/Nursing ___ CINAHL ___ Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews ___ Embase ___ ScienceDirect ___Other(s): Business ___ ABI/INFORM ___ Business Source Complete ___ IEEE Xplore Digital Library ___ Nexis Uni |
Databases: Social Sciences ___SocIndex ___ Public Administration Abstracts ___ Political Science Complete ___ APA PsycInfo ___Other(s): Education ___ ERIC ___ Education Source ___MedEdPortal ___Other(s): |
___GreyNet
___ Clinicaltrials.gov Advanced Search – Completed Studies ___Conference proceedings, white papers, etc. ___ ProQuest Dissertations and Theses __Other(s): Other Search Strategies ___Hand Searching (by journal, by author, general search engines or serendipity) ___ Citation Chaining (Ancestry/Progeny) ___Other(s): |
Remember: You need to develop a customized search for each database you use. Your searches should include natural and controlled language, multiple synonyms/keywords, Boolean logic, and database-specific syntax when needed.
Keeping a Search Log is required.
|
Timeline |
|
|
Date for Initial searches in gold search box on the Health Professions Research Page |
|
|
Implement organizational strategy and/or citation management software |
|
|
Consultation with librarian on search strategy to increase rigor and decrease bias |
|
|
Date for searches in additional databases |
|
|
Set up Search Alerts to be notified of new publications meeting your search criteria |
|
|
Circle back and evaluate your initial search with what you have learned; re-search |
1
8/19/2021
,
Integrative Review Literature Search Planning Form
This form is a starting point to help you brainstorm your search strategy while refining your research question. We strongly recommend consulting with a librarian when developing your search strategy. Go to Ask a Librarian in the Walden Library to email the Library team or to schedule an appointment.
Purpose:
Aim: In order to understand these updates and applications, how implementation scientists are integrating the concept of equity and intersectional approach within the CFIR framework will also be discussed.
|
Key Concepts, Synonyms, Search Terms |
Inclusion criteria |
Exclusion criteria |
|
|
Population |
Policymakers Healthcare personnel Researchers |
Research articles with the involvement of researchers and CFIR frameworks |
Any article without CFIR |
|
Problem of interest |
Updates in framework implementation strategies and challenges |
Articles that explain barriers and enablers of implementation |
Articles not related to implementation of change |
|
Context or Outcomes |
Implementation equity Implementation intersectionality |
Any real world application of CFIR in health settings |
Any theoretical paper on implementing change without references to the real world |
|
Literature/Study Types (be inclusive) · Qualitative · Quantitative · Observational · Theoretical · Experimental · Case reports · Meta-analysis · Mixed methods · Other (Grey Literature) |
Literature Types Include: What literature did you expect to find and what didn’t you find? |
Library Guide to the Literature Review and the Checklist for Exhausting the Literature. |
|
|
Publication limits for Inclusion/Exclusion Any reason the search should be limited by date and/or language? Years of publications (2020-2024 to obtain the most recent data) Languages – English (unless there is a reason to include other languages) |
|
Please list 5-10 relevant references to represent the articles expected in the results (include PMID or DOI, if possible): |
|
1. Damschroder, L. J., Reardon, C. M., Widerquist, M. A. O., & Lowery, J. (2022). The updated Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research based on user feedback. Implementation science, 17(1), 75. 2. Rodrigues, I. B., Fahim, C., Garad, Y., Presseau, J., Hoens, A. M., Braimoh, J., … & Straus, S. E. (2023). Developing the intersectionality supplemented Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR) and tools for intersectionality considerations. BMC Medical Research Methodology, 23(1), 262. 3. Escoffery, C., Riehman, K., Watson, L., Priess, A. S., Borne, M. F., Halpin, S. N., … & Kegler, M. C. (2019). Facilitators and barriers to the implementation of the HPV VACs (vaccinate adolescents against cancers) program: a consolidated framework for implementation research analysis. Preventing Chronic Disease, 16, E85. 4. Rangachari, P., Mushiana, S. S., & Herbert, K. (2022). A scoping review of applications of the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR) to telehealth service implementation initiatives. BMC Health Services Research, 22(1), 1450. 5. Wojcikiewicz Almeida, P., & Tavares Romay, G. (2024). Theoretical Framework: Participation Mechanisms Before the ICJ. In Expanding Access to Justice (pp. 21-63). Springer, Cham. |
|
Potential Databases/Search Strategies These databases are provided as examples. Talk to a librarian to explore other possible databases and see the Walden Library for other subject areas and combined-database search options. Linked to Walden Library subscriptions. |
||
|
Databases: Medicine/Nursing CINAHL PubMed ScienceDirect |
Databases: Social Sciences Soclndex Education ERIC |
Grey Literature (only if peer-reviewed scholarly literature is sparse) ProQuest GreyNet Other Search Strategies Citation chaining Hand searching |
Remember: You need to develop a customized search for each database you use. Your searches should include natural and controlled language, multiple synonyms/keywords, Boolean logic, and database-specific syntax when needed.
Keeping a Search Log is required.
|
Timeline |
|
|
Date for Initial searches in gold search box on the Health Professions Research Page |
January, 2023 |
|
Implement organizational strategy and/or citation management software |
Zotero |
|
Consultation with librarian on search strategy to increase rigor and decrease bias |
December, 2024 |
|
Date for searches in additional databases |
January, 2025 |
|
Set up Search Alerts to be notified of new publications meeting your search criteria |
January, 2025 |
|
Circle back and evaluate your initial search with what you have l |